An Update on Super Lines
By Paul Crawford
One of the hot topics on the water now are the
not-quite-so-new Super Lines. (In 1998, we did a comprehensive review that
still applies today). Suler Lines mostly consist of the
woven or braided fiber materials such as DuPont's Kevlar or
Allied Signals Spectra, although there are several others that
let you assume they are one of the above. I've been using these
super lines now for about 3 years and have at least tried it on
every rod and/or lure I own, with various success. I've heard
this type of line praised and cursed, sometimes in the same
breath. I'd thought I'd give the benefit of what I've learned
about this line, then let you be the judge if it's right for you.
First let's put to bed several misconceptions about what this
line does or doesn't do. None of the lines will; a) ruin your
guides, b) break your rods, c) require some exotic knot, d) never
break, or e) become an unmanageable mess the first back lash.
With the ceramic guides virtually all high quality bass rods come
with these days, this line doesn't stand a chance to even dent
it. Now it does sound terrible going through the guides on
a cast, so that it's carving its way through the tip is a natural
assumption, just not a true one. Even after a couple of thousand
hours of fishing on some of my rods, I've never seen the first
sign of wear on any of the eyes. I've never broken a rod with the
stuff either. My partner once went through 3 flipping sticks in
one month with 20 lb. mono, but no problems with braided line for
him either. The trick to this seems to be to avoid fishing a rod
much below 20 degrees air temperature and not lock the drag down
all the way prior to a big hook set. Also a pretty good idea is
to not use the rod to try to break the line. All of the lines
will break, sometimes with surprisingly little effort. If you are
going to break, do just the same as with any other heavy weight
line, grab the reel, (don't depend on the real seat), and pull
straight back. With anything less than a flipping hook and 50 lb+
line, you'll come undone by breaking the line or straightening
the hook. Most often, you'll pull open the eye of the hook get
back the knot, much more on that later. As far as
"professional overruns", this stuff will take one
fairly easy, but it's just as easy to undo and, unlike
monofiliment, won't damage the line.
Properties of Super Lines
The super lines share a number of physical properties
which set the aside from mere monofiliment. They have returned to
the days of braiding lines, a very similar process to the one
used to make Grampa's cotton line in the 40s. The difference is
in the fibers used for the braid. These materials are several
times stronger than steel, (which in this diameter really isn't
saying all that much), between fairly and extremely flexible,
depending are the particular material, and have a very close kit
molecular structure, which says they are extremely abrasion
resistant. The material itself has an extremely high yield point,
which means it won't stretch at all before breaking, yet is one
of the few high yield materials which isn't particularly brittle,
which is what makes it possible to use as kite string, (the
original intention), and fishing line.
So what does all of this mean to the fisherman. Compared to
monofiliment, the line is several times stronger for a given line
diameter. Most fishermen would agree 30 lb. test mono doesn't
cast as well as say 4 lb. test. Now you can have the tiny
diameter and still have all of the strength. You have to be
careful with this one, since you are use to having line which is
under rated in strength because the manufacturer doesn't want the
flak for his lines breaking at the weakest point. With the
braided lines, they are also under rated, but you won't find any
point that you think the line is about to let go, it just simply
goes with no warning. This leads to the conclusion that the line
isn't nearly as good as it actually is, it's just different. More
about this later. For now, quit thinking about line that will
never break. After playing with all of the high rated toys, say
50 lb. test and above, you'll end up back at something in the 20
to 30 lb. range, or just about where you were to start with. The
difference is in the other properties and the reduced diameter.
The smaller diameter means you can throw this stuff a mile, have
less resistance through the water even if it has a rougher
texture, and works wonderfully in the wind.
Since the line is braided, the sides don't have to stretch for
the line to bend. This gives you a line with no memory at all.
You can wad this stuff up in a little ball and it will stay that
way, even if happens to be on your reel at the time, (read
"very ugly backlash.") This is one of the lines most
endearing properties, and one of its biggest damnations. Since
this stuff doesn't keep a coil at all, it solves one of the
biggest draw backs we'd had with spinning reels, and works
exceptionally in that application. It also means that even if you
do have a professional overrun, it's very easy to pick out and
will do little or no damage to the line. It also means if you
strip it off the reel you can very easily have it tie itself in
knots of very tiny proportions. It also has a very pronounced
tendency to backlash if you get sloppy with your reel settings.
The trick to avoid this is to set your anti-backlash control
tighter and give back some of that increased casting distance
from the smaller diameter in return for fewer backlashes.
Everything in life is a trade off.
No stretch is the biggest advantage of the line. It means very
solid hook sets with reduced effort, and a feel of the lure you
never dreamed possible. You when first try this stuff, most
people actually have too much feel and it confuses them. Even the
tiniest weed or rock in 30 feet of water feels like a major
hydrilla ball. Let a crank bait or spinner bait touch a weed and
you'll swear it's a big bite. It takes some getting use to, and
the first big fish that hits it will jar you to your toes, but
after a short time, it simply becomes normal again. No more
"mush bite" on Carolina rigs, even with hands of stone
you'll feel the tick on this stuff. The advantage is most
especially true when fishing across the wind. You catch more fish
simply because you'll feel bites you never knew were there.
Close behind no stretch has to be how well these lines stand
up to fishing. The material is so hard that wood and weeds don't
stand a chance against it. If you are one of those folks who
loves to flip into heavy cover, have we got a line for you! Even
if you normally check your line and retie every hour, you may be
able to go A YEAR without retying. The only time I have ever
retied my flipping stick is to change baits or hooks. I've yet to
break off, although several of my hooks have seen better days.
You can saw this stuff all day long inside a fish attractor, and
the worst you might see is a bit of a fuss on the outer layer,
which I personally can't tell effects the line strength. Now
meaning that the weeds won't cut the line, I'm here to tell you
your teeth or fingernail clippers don't have a chance either.
Uncle Lou out at Culprit has a special pair of scissors for about
$6 which you will need to tie up this stuff. About the
only other good option is if you happen to be a smoker, all of
this stuff melts real easy, (read "be careful when
you smoke and fish.") Fair warning, if you take Momma's
stainless steel sewing scissors, they will work for a short
while, but you won't be popular when you get home.
Now, before let's all yell "Hooray" and bury
monofiliment beside bamboo rods, not all is rosy in paradise. It
turns out this material is so slick, it won't take any type of
dye for long, so get use to the idea of fishing with solid white
line. It also turns out we've grown to depend on the stretch and
memory of monofiliment to get the correct action out of our
lures. In addition to all of our lures, our reels were make to
handle monofiliment, not braids, so there are a few problems
there as well. Not to mention that even though the price has been
slashed by half in the last couple of years, you can still expect
to pay up to 10 times as much for this frustration. And to top it
off, not all braids are the same, and even lines made of the same
material are substantially different from different
manufacturers.
Brand Name Differences
Let me clearly state the following opinions are mine,
and I'm damn proud of them. I'm going to try to tell or warn you
about all of the brands I've tried, and my experience with them.
They aren't what the manufacturers would put in their ads, but I
will certify they are true. With that said, I'm going to list the
brands in reverse order, (worst to first), of what I use and
recommend, and try and tell you why. There is about 20 brands out
there, so we'll stick with the major suppliers commonly available
either locally or mail order.
Berkley - The only brand I absolutely recommend stay
away from like the Black Plague. Berkley's try at this, and
everyone needs a gimmick, was to appeal to those who couldn't tie
a good knot. With the largest size of the braided lines, the
knots tend to slip before the line breaks since the material is
rather slick. Their answer was a cored line with the braid around
a solid core which wasn't as flexible as the braid alone. This
was suppose to keep the knots tied up the line strength. It may
way have done it, but no one has ever had the line on long enough
to find out. Fortunately for me, I didn't buy this stuff, my
partner's in-laws sent it from out of state for him to try. After
about 8 hours fishing, the braid had separated and frayed every
18 inches or so for the entire length of the line. The line was
then only as strong as the core, which wasn't very, and retained
none of the properties of the original braid. In 8 hours it had
turned into a rather poor grade of monofiliment suitable only for
the trash can. Reflection now says even new out of the box, it
wasn't that good to begin with.
Stren - This is a Kevlar based line, undoubted because
Dupont also owns the patent rights to the material. It's not
actually all that bad, just a tick below the Spectra and other
polymers used by the rest of the world. It may be the best of the
lines for flipping heavy cover since the Kevlar has even more
abrasion resistance than the impressive resistance of other
lines. It just has a bit more memory because it's more brittle
than the other materials. The down sides are Kevlar resists a
knot more than other lines, (it's slicker), and if you kink it,
it will weaken at that point. Not bad, but there are better.
Bass Pro Spectra / Cabella's Ripcord - Both of these
brands seem to be the identical item, based on one of the
original weavers supply Lynch Line. Made of 100% Spectra, it has
all of the properties which are making the lines famous. The
drawback is that it is not woven as tightly as the other lines,
hence has a larger diameter and frays slightly easier. Available
primarily in 35 lb. and up sizes, the quality control is not as
good as other manufacturers so the breaking point of the weakest
area is unpredictable. None of the problems matter for 50 and 80
lb. test flipping line, so it is my choice for that application.
The real upside of these brands is they cost about 1/2 of what
other sources demand. A good choice for trying out braided line
for short line applications.
Fenwick Ironthread - Made a Japanese polymer, Fenwick's
claim to fame has been the wide range of line size and color they
have offered. Available from 2 lb., (slightly smaller than sewing
thread), to 130 lb. in 3 colors, they seem to have a line for
every application. Their only problems have been their material
takes a dye even worst than most, so bleaches almost immediately,
and their quality control. On the spools of Ironthread I've
tried, I always seem to come across a section which is much
weaker than the rest, so breaks noticeably easier. This can be
overcome by resetting the reel, but I don't like to guess when,
and don't like that I have to reset at all for premium priced
line. I do still use a 12 lb. test for ultralight fishing but may
switch soon as lighter lines become generally available from
other sources. Still, it's hard to beat their off brown color for
extremely clear water, if it would just stay that color for more
than a week.
Silver Braid - Another Japanese product, this one's
gimmick is a thin coating over the braid. This coating is suppose
to make casting easier, (just makes it quieter as far as I can
tell), but does give the line a slight amount of memory. It's
bright green color disappears surprisingly well in even clear
water while remaining very visible above the water. The coating
wears off fairly quickly, (the stuff is still slick), but it does
seem to retain it's color longer than other lines. It's my choice
for Spinner Baits and certain large top water lures fished on
heavy tackle, like big chuggers and Dalton Specials. The perfect
choice for the new A.C. Plugs.
Spider Wire - The most widely advertised, best known,
and most expensive of the braids. Still, for my money it's the
pick of the litter. Spider Wire has the tightest weave, and
therefore the smallest diameter of any of the lines. Their newest
product, Spectra 2000, is a full 40% smaller than the regular
Spider Wire, which was already the smallest on the market for a
given strength. Still fades, but will easily accept one of the
lure dyes on the market to recolor the line. The main reason I
like their brand is their exceptional quality control. You just
don't find weak points in the spool, and it is consistent between
spools. Spectra 2000 costs half again what most of the lines
cost, but to me it's worth it. The only reason I don't have it on
all of my reels is my 2 year old original Spider Wire still is
far from worn out.
Size
As I mentioned before, you will have to get use to a new scale
in measuring strength. Since the braids do not stretch, the
apparent breaking point feels lower than it actually is. For a
rough conversion, I would say that 30 lb. braid will break about
where a good quality 20 lb. mono will break. The reason for
difference is not all rating, some is fact. When you snap a hook
set with 20 lb. mono, it will stretch, taking some of the shock
out of the line. Not so with braids, the shock goes through the
entire line and the instantaneous forces generated by the lack of
acceleration of the fish on the other end can be enormous. Get
past all the engineering and you'll find you need to buy about
1/3 heavier rating in a braid than a comparable monofiliment. So,
if you use say 14 lb. monofiliment, try 20 lb. or so braid for
exactly the same strength. To make best use of the line, move up
in strength to say 30 lb., which in Spectra 2000, has the same
diameter as 6 lb. monofiliment. That way you get added strength and
reduced diameter. For flipping, if you use 30 lb. monofiliment,
the 50 lb. braid will do just fine. If you insist on being able
to straighten out a jig hook, the 80 lb. will do the job if you
don't rip the reel seat or bend the spool doing it.
For spinning reels, my personal favorite is 20 Spectra 2000,
having the same diameter as 4 lb. mono. Since I use spinning
reels for things I can't use something else for, light line is
good! If you are in the Roland Martin camp and use spinning rods
as your first choice, the 30 lb. test will out perform most of
your set up, especially your rod. Be aware of possible
spinning rod tip damage! Most spinning rods have the guide
support for the tip soldered to the back of the tube, keeping it
out of the line's way as it moves through the tip. This is great
for casting rods since if the line puts excessive pressure on the
tip, the eye bends out and the supports become big torsion bars
resisting the tension by pushing against the rod tube. If you
turn the eye over, such as a spinning rod tip, and apply the same
line tension, the support bars are pulling against the solder
joint, away from the rod tube. Translation, a spinning rod tip's
guide is only as strong as the solder joint. Be very careful when
going to line strengths with a higher rating than the rod's label
suggests. Spinning rods are normally rated, and limited, by the
rod tip's strength. Other than this limitation, you'll find
braided line as the best thing that ever happened to spinning
gear. No memory, says the line will resist, then ignore the twist
of both being placed on and off the reel, and of drag slip. You
can very safely use the reel's drag with braided line instead of
trying to back play the fish with the handle. It will be a
refreshing change to actually use your anti-reverse and drag! By
the way, setting the drag correctly will also minimize the chance
of damaging your rod tip, even on a hook set.
Knots
Unless you happen to use Stren's Kevlar, this is much ado
about nothing. I routinely use my old standby Palomar Knot to
attach just about every lure I own and break the knot even less
than I did when using the same knot with monofiliment. The same
can be said by my partner, who uses the Improved Cinch Knot. Both
knots seem to work very well and few if any of our breakoffs can
be traced to the knot.
Kevlar is a bit different. Most assume Kevlar is slicker or
the weave is tighter, neither of which is true compared to all
Spectra brands. The difference is Kevlar is less compressible, so
the knot can't tighten down on itself as well. This can be cured
by a variety of new knots most of which are old knots with the
line doubled, (a doubled Triline Knot works exceptionally well
much to the disappointment of Dupont and delight of Berkley.)
Another cure is Stren's Knot Glue which is a quick drying water
proof super glue. I avoid the problem by using a different line,
but for Kevlar fans, it will work with some effort.
Fenwick's Ironthread is another standout just because the
knots fail a bit more often. This is because their polymer is not
quite as flexible as the others and can be slightly damaged by
the knot tying process. It's still not bad, but a line failure
will normally occurs at the knot, which is knot all together bad.
Regardless of which knot you use, there is an interesting
problem to be aware of. Where you once were checking the line for
nicks and kinks, now check the hook eye. The braided lines are so
strong and small, they can easily work themselves around to the
gap left to make the eye. When this happens, you get nothing back
except the knot. If you pull your hook out of wood or rock, in
addition to seeing if the tip is bent, see if you have opened the
eye gap. This is naturally more of a concern with small hooks,
but I have left a disturbing number of 4/0 hooks on the bottom by
pulling through the eye.
Rods and Reels
Despite what the manufacturers of the "braid design"
reels say, just about any high quality reel will work. The key
feature is having a good drag which will reliably give on an over
strong hook set, preventing equipment damage. I use Shimano reels
and my partner uses Diawa. Neither of us have had any unexpected
failures or damage which has been caused by the line. The small
diameter line we use will dig into itself on our spools, but
nothing we can't immediately fix with a gentle tug. I'm sure the
wide wrap design of the "braid reels" are excellent for
extremely heavy line, such as 80 or 130 pound. Since I don't use
80 lb. for anything, I'll tell you all my reels handle up to 50
pound just fine. Keep your reel in good condition and clean and
service it on a regular basis, (regardless of line), and you'll
do fine too.
Rods are a different matter. I have changed my rod selection
for using braided lines. In general, I go lighter by one tip
weight for every application. For example I've gone from a 4 tip,
(med/heavy) to a 3 tip, (medium), for worms. Carolina Rigs went
from a 5 tip (Heavy) to a 4 tip. Crank baits stayed at a 2 tip,
but I tell you later that's because I don't use braided line for
crank baits. The reason for the lighter action is the lack of
stretch in the line. With monofiliment, I grew to depend on the
line compensating for the fish as I played him in. Since braids
don't stretch, I've had to go to a lighter action and let the rod
tip make up for the lack of line stretch. I could get away with
this since no stretch also meant I didn't need the extra rod
backbone for the hook set. Even with my flipping, I've gone from
a "flipping stick" to a "pitching stick"
which has a lighter action at the tip. The one exception to this
is my spinner baits, which I've always considered "cue stick
bubba fishin" anyway. Just remember to stay within the rod's
rated line range with spinning rods, and you should have no
problems.
Lures
I don't throw every lure made, but I think I've covered most
categories. The following is my thoughts on braided line
performance to date. I do reserve the right to change my mind at
most any time.
Texas Rigged Worms - The most popular lures in the area
seem to work great on braid. The rumor that the line, especially
after bleaching white, would put off the bite has been unfounded.
We tried side by side testing of braided line verses our old
stand by monofiliment for over six months with no perceptible
difference between number or quality of bite. Since the added
feel of the braid is especially important in deep water where I
often use a Texas Rig, this is a sure winner in my book.
Carolina Rigged Worms - The one application of
universal acceptance is Carolina Rigging. The only difference is
what type of leader to use. I personally think a monofiliment
leader works the best and adds to the action. I also like the
mono to act as a shock leader for big hook sets. My partner, on
the other hand, prefers to use a braided line leader as well.
Again, no perceptible difference in the number of quality of
bites. Just go with what makes you comfortable. By the way, a 12
or 14 lb. leader is also handy for those times you're hung and
need to break the line. The monofiliment still breaks easy so I
save alot on weights and swivels.
There is a word of caution on this. If you use glass beads,
(which I do exclusively), a chipped bead will cut the line
like a hot knife through butter. Using a brass weight with glass
beads will aggravate the problem. This really isn't any different
that with mono, you just notice it more since it is always
unexpected. There will be times when you set the hook and don't
even get back a smile. It's all part of the game and something
you get use to. On average, you'll still boat more fish than you
ever have, so just realize what's going on and don't sweat the
small stuff.
Spinner Baits - One of my favorite lures works wonders
on this line. Even the smallest blades feel like an Evanrude on
the other end. Not much way to miss a bite on this stuff either.
The only draw back is the weakest link in the system is now the
spinner bait wire, so you do tend to break a few baits if you
stay hung up most of the day, (at least you get the blade back.)
Some others feel like the line has too much feel and causes to
the jerk the bait away from a fish. It's the same school as likes
fiberglass rods over graphite for spinner baits and crank baits.
Personally, I can use all of the extra feel I can get.
Soft Jerk Baits - This is a problem category. I love
the added feel of the braided line, but have found out that the
lack of memory in the line is killing the normal action of my
bait. As a compromise, I have started using a monofiliment leader
for the baits, and this works wonders for me. If you don't like
the idea of tying up a leader with the associated tendency for
the bait to slowly sink, then I'd stick with monofiliment. Some
other users of braided line either don't think there is a
difference or wax the final 12 inches of their lines to retain
some spring. I will say that side by side tests of monofiliment
vs. all braid show the monofiliment will out catch the braid
about 3 to 1. There does not seem to be a difference between the
braid with a leader and monofiliment.
Hard Jerk Baits / Crank Baits - This is the one rod I
took the braided line off and was very happy. I found out that
even with a 2 tip, (light action), I still tended to pull treble
hooks out of a fish before he got in the boat. The added stretch
of monofiliment is an advantage for treble hook applications. I
recommend staying with your monofiliment for this one. By the
way, as with soft jerk baits, the line does seem to kill the
action and you get noticeably less bites. My partner, who just
loosens his drag and uses braided line because he shares the rod
between other applications, has taken to using a monofiliment
leader like I do with Soft Jerk Baits. This does correct the lure
action.
Top Waters - I have a cut off point for this one. My
personal cut off is 5/8 oz lures. Below that, I feel like the
lack of memory of the line and the loss of the spring in the line
hurts the action. In addition, playing a fish, I can easily pull
out small treble hooks, just like a crank bait. But over 5/8 oz,
the story changes. For Spooks, Magnum Jitterbugs, Dalton
Specials, and the like, I've always had trouble using heavy
enough line to control them. With the braided line I get the
addition control even at extreme casting range and can get a very
solid hook set, which has been hard at long range with
monofiliment. Since the treble hooks on these large baits are 1/0
or better, loosing the fish during a fight is not as great of
concern if I already have a good hook set.
Jigs - Ranks up there between Sex and Sliced Bread. Use
It!
Jigging Spoons - You have to be careful with this. The
added sensitivity is a definite plus, but the lack of memory is a
problem if you don't stay in control. If you just let the lure
flutter down any old way, the line will very quickly get tangled.
Adding a leader doesn't seem to help much. If you are good with a
jigging spoon, I suspect you have enough control to enjoy fishing
the braided line. If you are just starting, or only use a jigging
spoon on rare occasions, sticking with monofiliment will most
likely improve your day.
Swimming Spoons - I really like using braided line for
this application. The abrasion resistance lets me throw into the
deepest cover all day long without worrying about scraping the
line. The added sensitivity lets you tell between just another
weed a very light bite. All of my swimming spoons have a tying
ring anyway, so action is not a problem. For this application,
it's a winner.
Flipping - The American Express of Fishing Line. Don't
Leave Home Without It.
Tube Jigs and Grubs - One of the few applications where
the lack of memory actually improves the lure action. Stay with
the smaller sizes, with less water resistance, and you'll get
improved action on the drop which will turn into several extra
bites a day. All this and you actually get to feel the bites too!
Ultra Lights - In addition to tubes and grubs, I also
throw weenie worms and tiny crank baits, along with the assorted
3" Slug-O or Beetle Spin. If you stay with the same
test or slightly higher line, you get improved action and the
line will disappear in water. When using weenie worms or Slug-Os,
I still put a piece of monofiliment as a shock leader, just as I
do with Carolina rigs. Most of crank baits in this size start
coming with either a tiny swivel or snap ring, so action is not a
problem. Exerting too much pressure on the tiny hooks is
difficult to do with very light action rods, but keep a loose
drag just in case. Some trade offs here but I still keep braided
line on my spool.
Micro Lights - Assuming you use 2 - 4 lb. braided line
maximum, this is more fun that the law allows. The added
sensitivity is unreal and the lure action unbelievable. Your line
is almost precisely the same diameter as air, only stronger. The
only challenge bigger than landing a 3 lb. bass on this tackle is
trying to tie on a bait without glasses.
Fishing the Super Lines
The biggest differences in fishing Super Lines are the reel
settings and hook sets. Once you get use to the feel of the
lures, the rest is simple. You may find it surprisingly difficult
to get the correct drag set on your reel. When you test your
drag, you have been use to the stretch in the line between your
hand and the reel, which is now gone. Set the drag where it will
just give a bit when you set the hook. If you're one of those
folks who set their hook with the same motion they swing a bat,
go back to reeling down and popping the hook with your arms and
wrists. The only time you need a bigger hook set is with a
Carolina, which is still less than half of what you use with the
same rig now. DO NOT compensate for casting distance! The hook
set should be the same for a mile long cast or right under the
boat. The only time you have to worry about slack is if the wind
has a bow in your line, then reel up to the fish before setting.
If you start to loose fish you stick, then the problem can just
as easy be too tight of drag as too loose. Chances are pretty
good if you use a big hook set of the hook ripping the fish's
mouth, and without having a limber rod, the least amount of slack
is going to loose the fish. Once the fish is hooked, reel like
hell! You are not going to get the benefit of spring tension
with the braided line, so it will be much easier for the fish to
get some slack, hence the recommendation to go to a lighter rod
action.
About the only other thing I can think of is to stick to one
line for a lure class. If you try to switch between monofiliment
and braid throwing say a Texas Rig Worm on both, you'll get
frustrated in a hurry. The feel is different, the hook set is
different, it will cast different, and you'll never remember
which one you have in your hands when that big bite comes. If
you're going to try braided line, pick a lure and just worry
about one line at a time. The feel of the lure is already going
to be different than anything else, so it's not as big a deal to
switch lines when you switch lures as well. Make sure you take a
few practice trips with the braid to get use to it before trying
it with money on the line. Even a new race car needs a few
practice laps before going to competition.
Paul Crawford
|